Another decade, another attempt to revive Alone in the Dark. I’ve recently covered all of the previous games in the series (excluding Illumination, because who cares). The inspiring original trilogy that shaped modern action adventures, but aged poorly. A much simpler first reboot The New Nightmare that nonetheless did several incredibly ambitious things. Overly ambitious Alone in the Dark from 2008, that attempted to reinvent the genre but failed miserably. And now we have a third game simply titled Alone in the Dark, except this lacks any ambition of the previous entries.
Tag: Not recommended
Disapprove: Homefront and Homefront: The Revolution
There’s something fascinating about seeing two attempts at creating a game franchise fail so miserably as it happened with Homefront. I can understand why the publishers thought there was potential here – a franchise of FPS titles built around an idea of war happening on US soil. It could be provocative and novel and independently of quality of the end product guarantee to cause at least some uproar and publicity, positive or not. And its not like the attempts were the same, they tried approaching the same basic idea from rather different perspectives. Yet, both of them are very much not good and not worth playing at all.
Read more“Disapprove: Homefront and Homefront: The Revolution”
Disapprove: Secret of Mana (2018)
Three years ago I’ve played the Trials of Mana remake which was my first introduction to the Mana (Seiken Densetsu) series. It was a very simple, but extremely fun and exciting action RPG that had the energy and ideas of the 90s redone with all of the experience and sensibilities of the 2020s. Countless games were inspired by Secret of Mana, and Ys and thousands of hack and slash games and their experience was poured into making Trials of Mana 2020, making it a fun experience a lot of modern players can instantly get into.
And now I’ve played Secret of Mana remake from 2018, which actually feels like a game from 1993 and it’s been a miserable experience throughout. Surprisingly, from what I’ve gathered, partially because some things in this remake made the game worse.
Disapprove: Diablo IV
What’s really unpleasant with the sunk-cost fallacy is when you know you’re engaging in it but is too stupid and stubborn to stop. Anyway, Diablo IV is the most miserable time I’ve had with any action RPG in my life and I’ve still wasted 55 hours on it. I really should’ve refunded it in the first hour, but… I mean, it’s “Diablo” and I have positive things to say even about the third game, as it can be very enjoyable if shallow. But this… oh boy, this was horrible.
Disapprove: Trine 5: A Clockwork Conspiracy
Trine series are a weird beast. The original wasn’t good, but had a lot of really cool ideas. All of which got majorly improved in the sequel, which was the first genuinely enjoyable title in the series. Then Trine 3 was released in Early Access and remained unfinished, mixing lots of very bad ideas with some of the genuinely best ideas in the franchise. And then Trine 4 came along and was mostly a straight up improvement again returning to the formula of 2, but making it more fun and adding fresh ideas. First hours with Trine 5 felt like I was playing 4 again, but with some tweaks and changes. It was charming, as always, and quite fun to play. But the more I played, the less fun the game got. And almost at the end of the game I gave up fed up with horrible design.
O tempora: Alone in the Dark 1, 2, 3
O tempora is a series of retrospective posts where I play games from ages before to see if they stood the test of time.
It’s been a while since I’ve last played any Alone in the Dark game. I admired the original and genuinely liked the 2008 game despite all of its numerous flaws. My favorite one was the first reboot, Alone in the Dark: The New Nightmare. But the original still had that “something” about it that I really liked. Not the sequels, however. But for the sake of revisiting every game, I decided against my better judgement to play all of the first three Alone in the Dark games, knowing well that I will not enjoy the two thirds of the journey.
Thoughts on: Crysis Remastered Trilogy
I’ve revisited the original Crysis and Crysis Warhead just 3 years ago and that was the first time these titles at least somewhat clicked with me. As I’ve mentioned – I never found any of the titles in the franchise, apart from Crysis 3, to be all that fun. But replaying the first games, as rough as those original games are today, made me understand why someone would like them. Now that all numbered Crysis titles have gotten a Remastered release (sadly, Warhead was not remastered), I decided to play them and see if I can actually enjoy the experience.
Disapprove: Resident Evil Village – Winters’ Expansion
Two years ago I’ve completed Resident Evil Village and while my first playthrough of it was very entertaining, it turned out to be the least replayable RE game for me. I got bored on my third playthrough, while trying to unlock more stuff as I usually do, and found myself so utterly bored with the game that I stopped and haven’t looked at it since then. That is, until Winters’ Expansion, a new DLC, got released and I’ve finally decided to play it. At worst I expected this to be more of the same and, following this logic, at least fun on the first playthrough. But no. It wasn’t fun even the first time around.
Read more“Disapprove: Resident Evil Village – Winters’ Expansion”
Disapprove: The Callisto Protocol
I didn’t expect a lot from The Callisto Protocol – just a solid survival action game. I didn’t expect it to be as amazing as the first Dead Space, didn’t even expect it to be that much better than Dead Space 3, in ways in which it could be better at least. And after the disastrous launch when the game was entirely unplayable on PCs I’ve lowered my expectations even further. But the game still managed to disappoint.
Disapprove: Scorn
I know people have expected a lot from Scorn. Ever since the “gameplay trailer” the developers released 5 years ago, there was a lot of excitement for both the visual style and the fact that it included combat and seemed to aim at being a proper action horror game, not just a typical for the time horror themed adventure where you run away all the time. But I’ve had my reservations and the closer to release the game go, the more suspicious the trailers seemed to me so I wanted to wait and see what happens. A lukewarm reception is what happened, so I’ve decided to return to the game later, on a discount. But even that and low expectations didn’t make the experience with this game good.